YouTube - CNN - The Good, Bad & Ugly of Obama's Economic Speeches
Primary Language: English
I appeared on CNN on 1/9/09 to discuss the good, bad and ugly of Barack Obama's recent speeches on the economy.
My Recent Work
You did not do any work on this video
Information Tags
Timing Category Subcategory Tag
00:00:05 People Known People Barack Obama
00:00:16 Places City Denver
00:00:19 People Occupation Author
00:01:11 People Occupation Fence
00:01:27 People Known People John Mccain
00:02:54 People Known People John Dickerson
00:03:01 Places US State Washington
00:03:05 Others Brand Doom
00:03:47 Places City Denver
Subtitles in: English
Start End Subtitles
00:00:00 00:00:04 David Sirota's new book, The Uprising, is available in bookstores everywhere.
00:00:05 00:00:08 President elect, Barack Obama, is warning of dire economic situation,
00:00:09 00:00:13 and how much worse it could get if there is not bipartisan support, and quickly,
00:00:13 00:00:16 for his stimulus plan. But will his proposals work?
00:00:16 00:00:19 Joining me now from Denver is nationally syndicated columnist, David Sirota.
00:00:19 00:00:21 He is also the author of the book, The Uprising.
00:00:22 00:00:24 David, you wrote a column yesterday, fascinating one.
00:00:24 00:00:26 In the immediate aftermath of the Obama speech called,
00:00:27 00:00:29 "The Good, The Bad and The Ugly of the Plan". Let's walk through it.
00:00:29 00:00:31 What the good first?
00:00:32 00:00:37 The good is that Obama seems to understand, at least the size and scope of the problem,
00:00:37 00:00:41 and is proposing a robust package of public spending.
00:00:41 00:00:46 And we know that public spending is probably the most efficient way to stimulate the economy.
00:00:46 00:00:49 Some people, though, are saying that there isn't enough public spending in this.
00:00:49 00:00:56 Well, it gets to the bad. The bad part of this is that he is also including a lot of tax cuts
00:00:57 00:01:02 and he seems to be paying for those tax cuts with that public spending.
00:01:02 00:01:06 In other words, he's taking the money that could be going to public spending,
00:01:06 00:01:11 and proposing putting it into a lot of tax cuts that a lot of people don't think are gonna work.
00:01:11 00:01:14 So why do you say the tax cuts are bad? Because if you look at the other side of the political fence,
00:01:15 00:01:17 or on the Republican side, they believe that the tax cuts are good
00:01:17 00:01:19 and there probably needs to be more of them.
00:01:20 00:01:24 Well, because the data tells us that the best way, the quickest way, the most efficient way,
00:01:24 00:01:27 to stimulate the economy, is through public spending.
00:01:27 00:01:31 Mark Zandi of, one of John McCain's advisors,
00:01:32 00:01:37 had said that you get about $1.58 GDP benefit with public spending.
00:01:37 00:01:42 You only get $1.23 or $1.24 when you put that money into tax cuts.
00:01:42 00:01:46 So, if we want to stimulate the economy in a short term, quick kinda way,
00:01:46 00:01:50 the best way that we know how to do that is through public infrastructure spending,
00:01:51 00:01:53 unemployment insurance, food stamps.
00:01:53 00:01:56 We'll get to the ugly in just a second David, but do you have enough information
00:01:57 00:02:00 about what's in this plan to be able to say whether or not it would work?
00:02:02 00:02:07 Not yet, and that's a good point. We don't know what the final size of the package is gonna be.
00:02:08 00:02:13 We don't know what percentage is gonna spending, what precise percentage is gonna be tax cuts.
00:02:13 00:02:18 It's still a negotiation in process, that's absolutely true.
00:02:18 00:02:20 Alright, so give us the ugly of all of this.
00:02:21 00:02:28 Well, the ugly was that Obama seemed to mention that he wants to connect deficit reduction
00:02:28 00:02:31 to entitlement, "entitlement reform."
00:02:31 00:02:34 Now, entitlement reform refers to social security and Medicare.
00:02:34 00:02:40 Now when you tie deficit reduction to entitlement "reform", it usually has meant in the past
00:02:41 00:02:46 efforts to try to cut those programs. That's a bad idea in a bad economy.
00:02:47 00:02:51 Medicare and social security are very, very stimulative to the economy.
00:02:52 00:02:53 You do not want cut those programs.
00:02:54 00:02:57 There was one other aspect to all of this that John Dickerson from Slate Magazine
00:02:58 00:03:00 picked up, he noticed how this was being sold. He writes,
00:03:01 00:03:05 "For a president who has repeatedly promised an entirely new way of doing business in Washington,
00:03:05 00:03:10 Obama's address had a deep familiarity: Doom was its central and recurring message.
00:03:10 00:03:13 Unless the federal government acts quickly and boldly (and expensively),
00:03:13 00:03:15 the roof is going to cave in."
00:03:15 00:03:18 It's almost like he's using the tactics of the Bush administration.
00:03:18 00:03:21 As it sold security, to try to sell us economic recovery package.
00:03:23 00:03:26 I think there is something to that but I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing.
00:03:26 00:03:32 Every crisis is an opportunity and I think that this economic crisis is an opportunity
00:03:33 00:03:38 to reassert the role of the government as a force for good in the economy
00:03:38 00:03:39 on behalf of the middle class.
00:03:40 00:03:44 We haven't had that in the last 30-35 years. And I do think that that's a paradigm shift,
00:03:44 00:03:47 at least from the past couple of decades.
00:03:47 00:03:50 David Sirota in Denver this morning. It's good to see you David, thanks for coming in.
00:03:51 00:03:52 Thanks for having me John.
Copy and paste the embed code above
Copy and paste the embed code above